Monday, April 14, 2008

After hours of pondering what to say in this blog, I decided to grab the steer by the horns and simply pull him down. For the last few days, I’ve been watching the response to an author’s underhanded tactics of removing less than four or five star reviews for her books on Amazon.

I am, as are many others, appalled to believe that a romance writer would do this. I’m proud that I write romance and I have some great friends who are also romance authors. Leave it to one bad apple to ruin the whole basket.

Some of the comments in response to this situation sent chills up my back. What the woman did was horrid but the decision by several reviewers ‘not read anymore romances’ and another comment of ‘this turned them off for romance books’ added the candle to the top of the cake. This can’t be happening but it is. I hope most of the reviewers realize that this is a few authors and not to assume the entire genre does this.

And why? Because the matter of trust between the readers and the authors have been severely damaged by a woman who decided she was above reproach. This is not good for the rest of us. Personally, I feel violated by what this author has done. For those of us that are thrilled to see what reviewers say about our works, whether it’s good or bad, her actions have destroyed the link holding us together.

Me? I want the good with the bad. I want to know what reviewers think so I can improve and hopefully write a better book because of it. This is a sign of being a professional. We as authors need to remember we are in the public eye and not only will our works but our professional image will make or break us in this field.

My mother always taught me the ‘Golden Rule’. Obviously, others never learned it. They should have. The internet is a fabulous tool but it can also be someone’s downfall. There’s too much information and if you’re caught lying, bullying, it will be remembered. This isn’t the type of mark you want branded on you when you’re striving to be a successful author. Nope, not at all.

posted by Judith Leger at 3:16 PM |

6 Comments:

At April 14, 2008 at 3:37 PM, Blogger Gina Ardito aka Katherine Brandon said........
I couldn't agree more, Judy. We're in a "public" business, and as such, we owe ourselves and our readers the gift of professionalism. Still, we are also human. And each of us will show our feet of clay at one time or another.

Here's hoping readers can forgive us our foibles and appreciate our stories even when we stumble!

And to all authors out there, please remember there's more to our business than five stars and the NY Times Bestseller list. There are readers behind our books! Without them, we are nothing.
 


At April 14, 2008 at 3:43 PM, Blogger Unknown said........
There are two underlying expectations to what was done that just floor me.

One, that only positive reviews should be left. Hello? Why? and How?

Which leads to two, that everyone will love your work. Hello?, again?. How? Even the best selling living author, and, yes, I am referring to JKR, has her detractors.

The expectation that only 'good' reviews should be 'allowed' is just hogwash. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. You don't have to agree with it, but don't say it is invalid.

It's just wrong, wrong, wrong on so many levels.

And then to make the jump that since 'writer a' who writes romances, has done this all romance writers are then 'bad'?

*That* logic is even faultier than 'writer a's '.

I am just shaking my head over the whole thing.
 


At April 14, 2008 at 6:42 PM, Blogger Shari Boullion said........
Oh, gaming the review system is just wrong. I'm glad you brought this up--I had no idea authors could do this.

And, I agree with you. If you're going to write, you have to have enough guts to take the bad reviews with the good. If you can't, either write better books or quit the business.

Pooey, now I'm going to have to wonder about all the reviews on Amazon.
 


At April 14, 2008 at 9:18 PM, Blogger Kada. said........
Something my friend(now husband) said to me will always stick in my memory. Once it's out on the internet, it's impossible to remove it from the public eye, and you've got no idea who's accessing that information. So choose very carefully what info or pictures you share.

That was in response to this complete Internet newbie having my Real details up when I joined a yahoo group many, many years ago.

Over the years I've been appalled at some of the things I've seen s'posedly professional people do or say about other people. Especially when it's people who're buying their product!

If a review upsets you, rant in private to your friends and family, or a private blog and hope no one copies and pastes. Not out in public for all to see.

On the flipside, I'm also appalled at what people will say and do to other people on the internet, in reviews, emails etc, and not always hidden behind that ubiquitous tool of cowards--anonymous.

It all boils down to lack of respect on both sides. Not to mention all too often write and send, instead of write, review when calmed down then send.
 


At April 15, 2008 at 1:22 PM, Blogger Pamela S Thibodeaux said........
I agree with all of these ladies, Judy and I agree with you that we are professionals and should behave as such.

I've read the rants you're referring to and I believe those readers who are disappointed will also see that we authors are not all like the few who do this sort of thing.

Of course, we all make mistakes in our career but hopefully they are not the unredeemable kind.

Great post!
 


At April 15, 2008 at 9:31 PM, Blogger Sandra Cormier said........
My message for those who decide to stop reading romance because of the occasional misbehaving author: don't know what you're missing when there are so many more mature, professional and kick-ass romance writers out there.